Yosef brought his brothers’ evil report to their father. Why would the Torah tell of a tzaddik carrying such a report, and what could it have to do with the manna’s “six days you shall gather it,” the Shabbos boundary, and the Musaf offering?
These are the generations of Yaakov: Yosef, being seventeen years old, was tending the flock with his brothers, and he was a lad with the sons of Bilhah and the sons of Zilpah, his father's wives; and Yosef brought their evil report to their father.
31Or we may read “And Yosef brought their evil report …” as speaking of the tzaddik who rises to the level of Musaf, the “additional” offering and prayer of Shabbos. We begin with the verse “Six days you shall gather it, and on the seventh day, Shabbos, there will be none.”1 It seems to me that all six weekdays a person must serve the Creator, blessed be He, with fear and with love: he must see his own lowliness and the greatness of God. Through this he raises the holy sparks, the fragments of holiness that fell to the outside forces. That is the hint in “Six days you shall gather it”: gather the holy sparks all six weekdays. Then “on the seventh day, Shabbos, there will be none.” When Shabbos comes, all the kelipos, the husks that hide holiness, fall of themselves to nukva diTehoma Rabba, the depths of the great abyss, and have no hold at all on holiness. This is what the verse says a few lines later: “Sit each man tachtav,” in his place, words that also mean “beneath him.”2 On Shabbos the outside forces have fallen down and lie beneath a person. You must sit on them and subdue them, and from now on not let them raise their head at all for the coming week.
In shortGathering the holy sparks through fear and love all week makes the husks fall away on Shabbos; then a person must “sit” on them so they cannot rise in the coming week.
32Yet the verse tells us that even with all this a person has not done his duty. He must rise to a still higher level: “Let no man go out of his place.” From these words Chazal learned the techum, the Shabbos boundary of two thousand amos.3 The Shechinah is called Makom, “Place.” This is the meaning of “Whoever fixes a place for his prayer”:4 with his prayer he raises the lower Shechinah and fixes her to the upper Shechinah. When the tzaddik then rises to the upper place, the upper Makom, the angels ask, “What has God wrought?”5 This is their question in the Kedushah, asked of the upper place the tzaddik has reached: “Where is the place (makom) of His glory?”6 That is why the verse commands, “Let no man go out of his place.” All the weekdays the worlds are mati velo mati, “reaching and not reaching.” So the tzaddik too must spend all the days of the week reaching and not reaching: he must go out from the level of love to fear, and from fear to love. But on holy Shabbos the worlds rise as they were before the sin, for Shabbos is the world of tikkun, of things set right. Then the tzaddik too must stand on this level and not go out of his upper place. This is “the olah of Shabbos on its Shabbos, besides the continual olah.”7 The olah, the burnt offering, is named for going up. The weekday olah goes by reaching and not reaching, up and then down. But “the olah of Shabbos” stays beshabbato, at rest above, with no reaching down at all.
Bamidbar 23:23. Rashi there: in time to come the place of the righteous will be within that of the ministering angels, and the angels will ask them, “What has God wrought?” ↩
In shortAll week the tzaddik moves between love and fear, reaching and withdrawing; on Shabbos, when the worlds rise to their tikkun, he must stay in his upper place and not go out.
33aChazal derived two thousand amos from “Let no man go out …” as a hint to two alafim, two thousands: a thousand (elef) of Chochmah, wisdom, and a thousand of Binah, understanding. Chochmah is called Ayin, “nothing,” and this is the meaning of Hillel's words, “If I am not for myself …”8Im ein ani, “if I am not,” is read here as “if ani is in ayin.” When the tzaddik rises to the level of Chochmah, he is called Ani, “I.” That is, he no longer needs to go down and make himself humbled and lowly, like one who is ayin, nothing [in the plain sense]. He is called Ani like a man who says “I am,” in the manner of “I am, and there is none besides me.”9 And ani (אני) has the letters of ayin (אין): the letters of the one are the letters of the other. So “if ani is in ayin” means: if my “I” stands at the level of Chochmah, the Ayin. Then mi li, “who is for me,” becomes “Mi is mine”: I have fully perfected the world called Mi, “Who.” That is the world of Binah, where all the harsh judgments are sweetened at their root, so that no judgment rules in the world.
Avos 1:14. In the language of Kabbalah, Chochmah is called Ayin, “nothing,” after Iyov 28:12, “And wisdom, from nothing (me'ayin) shall it be found.” ↩
In shortThe two thousand amos hint at Chochmah and Binah: the tzaddik who rises to Chochmah, Ayin, becomes Ani, and perfects Binah, Mi, where every judgment is sweetened at its root.
33bThis is Hillel's “If I am here, everything is here.”10 If I am on the level of Ani, then “everything is here”: the level called Kol, “everything,” is set right. Kol is the sefirah of Yesod, “foundation,” which is called “the tzaddik, the foundation of the world,”11 and then the judgments have no power to rule in this world. This is “I have set Hashem before me always.”12 Because I have set right the Name Havayah, the four-letter Name, blessed be He, above, I have brought it about that in this world too there will always be complete compassion. “Before me” (lenegdi) hints at this world, which is in front of me. And the meaning of “a thousand of Chochmah and a thousand of Binah” is now clear of itself. When the tzaddik is in his upper place, having risen to the level of Chochmah, “the thousand of Binah” is perfected in full, and there is no harm at all.
Sukkah 53a, said by Hillel at the rejoicing of the water-drawing. ↩
Mishlei 10:25. In the language of Kabbalah, Yesod is called both “tzaddik” and Kol, “all,” after Divrei HaYamim I 29:11, “for all (kol) that is in heaven and on earth.” ↩
In shortWhen the tzaddik stands at Ani, Kol, Yesod, the foundation of the world, is set right and Hashem's Name is perfected above, so this world has complete compassion and no judgment rules it.
33cThis is what Chazal said: one who goes out beyond the techum has four amos in every ruach, every direction.13 Here going out beyond the techum is rising still higher than the level of Chochmah, which is the inner meaning of Musaf. The tzaddik who rises that high has the “four amos of halachah”14 in every ruach. Even the north side of the world, which is left without a wall for the reason the Sages give,15 falls within them. There too he brings about what the verse says: “And the northern one I will remove far from you.”16 Then “the ruach of impurity,” the spirit of impurity, will pass from the land,17 and the north side will no longer need to stand open without a wall.
Eruvin 51a; Rashi on Shemos 16:29: from here the Sages based the four amos for one who goes out beyond the techum. ↩
Berachos 8a: since the Beis HaMikdash was destroyed, the Holy One, blessed be He, has in His world only the four amos of halachah. ↩
Bava Basra 25b: the north side of the world is not enclosed. The reason is in Pirkei deRabbi Eliezer 3: Hashem made the northern corner and left it unfinished, so that whoever claims to be a god may come and finish it; and from there evil goes out to the world. ↩
In shortThe tzaddik who rises beyond Chochmah holds the “four amos of halachah” in every direction, even the open north, so the spirit of impurity passes from the land.
34This is “And Yosef brought their evil report to their father.” This tzaddik is called Yosef (יוסף), a hint that he stands on the great level we have described, the level of Musaf (מוסף). Dibasam, “their report,” means the brothers' evil report, but here it is read as all the spoiled deeds. Yosef brings them to their Father in heaven, where everything is null and void and has no substance. “And Yisrael loved Yosef”:18 “Yisrael” here is the Holy One, blessed be He, Who is also called by that name, as we said in an earlier teaching on this verse, of Yosef who raises the Shechinah up to Chochmah. His chief love is for the tzaddik who rises to the level of Musaf. This is what Rachel said: “God has gathered away my disgrace … and she called his name Yosef.”19 At first glance she should have called him Asaf, “gathered,” since she said “God has asaf.” But the hint is to what we have said: God gathered away all the disgraces and the lowliness, and everything was annulled. “And she called his name Yosef”: through the root of the name, the root of Musaf, she hinted at the level of Musaf.
In shortYosef, the tzaddik at the level of Musaf, brings every spoiled deed before the Father in heaven, where it is annulled; so Hashem loves him above all, and Rachel named him for that level.
35This is what meant: “Yaakov wished to dwell in tranquility.”20 Yaakov was on this level, where he had forced all the judgments down beneath him, and so he wished to dwell in tranquility. “The trouble of Yosef sprang upon him”: this follows the way we explain “And Yosef dreamed a dream and told it to his brothers, and they hated him yet more.”21 We may say that the brothers of Yosef, tzaddikim that they were, meant it for Yosef's good. They heard him say, “I dreamed a dream,”22 and the letters of chalam (חלם), “dreamed,” are those of machal (מחל), “forgave.” So they understood that he would rise to greatness, as it is taught: “A person does not rise to greatness unless all his sins are forgiven him.”23 That is why “they hated him yet more”: so that through this he would be strengthened still more to rise to a great level. The same holds for “the trouble of Yosef sprang upon him”: it came so that he would rise to a great level, the level of Musaf. And this too is “And Yisrael loved Yosef.”
Yosef's words are “Hear, please, this dream that I have dreamed” (Bereishis 37:6) and “Behold, I have dreamed another dream” (Bereishis 37:9). ↩
Rashi on Bereishis 36:3, from the Midrash on Shmuel: three have their sins forgiven, among them “one who rises to greatness.” Yerushalmi Bikkurim 3:3: “Greatness atones”; a sage who is appointed is forgiven all his sins. ↩
In shortThe brothers' hatred and Yaakov's trouble were both for the good: chalam, dreamed, spells machal, forgave, and the pressure was meant to lift the tzaddik to the level of Musaf.
36This is “Who builds His aliyos, His upper chambers, in the heavens.”24 It hints at the tzaddikim called bnei aliyah, people of ascent: by their deeds they build new heavens. They bring about “and His band (agudaso) upon the earth,” all the bands of people that are upon the earth. “He founded it”: He founds them in compassion, without harm, and everything is complete compassion. Understand this.
Amos 9:6. The verse reads ma'alosav, “His upper chambers.” ↩
In shortTzaddikim of ascent build new heavens with their deeds, and every gathering on earth is then founded in complete compassion, free of harm.
The maamar as a whole
R’ Elimelech begins with the manna. All week a person gathers the holy sparks through fear and love, and on Shabbos the husks fall away and must be held down beneath him. Yet more is asked: on Shabbos, when the worlds rise to their tikkun, the tzaddik who moved between love and fear all week must not go out of his upper place, as the Shabbos olah stays above. The two thousand amos are Chochmah and Binah: when his “I” stands in Chochmah, the Ayin, Binah is perfected and every judgment is sweetened. Going beyond the techum is rising higher still, to Musaf, the level of Yosef, who brings every spoiled deed before the Father in heaven to be annulled. Even the brothers’ hatred and Yaakov’s trouble came to lift him there.
Takeaway
All week we gather the sparks with fear and love, rising and falling; on Shabbos we can hold our place above and keep the husks beneath us. And the trouble that breaks our rest may be what lifts us to the level of Musaf, where every spoiled deed is brought before our Father in heaven and annulled.